Debate On "What If... Sceanarios"

[Sun Quan]

All debates on topics such as "what would happen if Yuan Shao had won at Guan Du", should be directed here.

[Cao Cao]

Ok I will start, I guess.....

"What if Mi Zhu didn't die of anguish from his brother?"

[Sun Quan]

Well, he was very old by that time, and will have died in a few short years I expect, but if he had lived until Huang Hao came into power, he might have prevented Jiang Wei getting no support.

[Cao Cao]

Acctualy I think he was only in his late 40's to early 50's. And as we know his sister died at Chang Ban, Madam Mi was Mi Zhu's sister. And if it hadn't been for Mi Zhu, Liu Bei could have never gotten over the deafeat they recieved from Lu Bu.

[Sun Quan]

Then again, 50 was quite old for that time period.

[Mazza Yu]

true, here's a good one, what is is what if Sun Jian had lived when he was killed when he went 2 jing

[Pang Tong]

... then I don''t think Yuan Shu would have ever gotten the Imperial Seal, I think.

[Ma Chao]

What if Sun Ce never died at that young age and lived to the battle of Yi Ling, etc.

[Pang Tong]

hmm that's a tough one I need to think for a while. While I'm thinking here's one from me.

What if Pang Tong didn't die from a stray arrow and Zhuge Liang didn't pull out of Jing to save Liu Bei?

[Guan Yu]

Sun Ce not Die well Xu chang Would have fallen to him. Cao Cao could not have beat Yuan Sha and him. Sun Ce take centaral plains. him and Shao Fight. Liu Bei takes Yi.